Critics weigh in on Germany′s coalition talks ′breakthrough′ | News | DW | 12.01.2018

Finding Germany's next government

Critics weigh in on Germany's coalition talks 'breakthrough'

Germany's prospective deal for Chancellor Angela Merkel to head another grand coalition has been slammed by industry leaders as "expensive." Asylum advocates say it hands hard-liners a "triumph" over human rights.

Watch video 00:52

Reactions on German coalition talks breakthrough

Elements of a 28-page policy paper backed Friday by Merkel and Social Democratic Party (SPD) leader Martin Schulz as the basis for recommended formal coalition talks  have quickly drawn criticism.

Read more: Another Merkel-led coalition

Mario Ohoven, president of Germany's BVMW federation of medium-sized industrial companies, said a further coalition — potentially Merkel's third with the SPD since 2005 — would be "costly for Germany."

The outcome of six days of exploratory talks that peaked early Friday would raise the cost of labor, worsen competition and ignore the need for tax competitiveness, Ohoven asserted.

President of the German Chamber of Commerce (DIHK), Eric Schweizer, said the prospect of a government being formed after a 3-month hiatus was "important and good" but that a great policy vision was not discernible.

Watch video 02:01

Germany's SPD, CDU agree to try to find common ground

Left: 'social injustice' perpetuated

Left party chairwoman Sahra Wagenknecht said the deal would perpetuate "blatant social injustice," including Germany's precarious low-wage sector and poverty in old age, while business raked in "gushing dividends."

 Sahra Wagenknecht in German parliament (Reuters/H.Hanschke)

Social injustice is being perpetuated, says Wagenknecht

Pro Asyl (Pro Asylum), a church-backed lobby group, slammed as "injurious" the prospective coalition's aim to keep refugee arrivals below 220,000 annually and to first sort applicants at centers into those to be expelled or forwarded to municipalities.

"That is a triumph by hard-line [politicians] over humanity and human rights," said Pro Asyl, despite the paper's claim that the right to asylum remained untouched.

Germany's large SoVD and VdK social welfare associations welcomed the intention set out in the paper to restore parity in the way employees and employers pay into statutory health funds. Currently, workers alone shoulder a supplementary charge.

The VdK, representing 1.8 million members, also welcomed the prospective coalition's intention to fix acute shortages of nursing personnel for senior residents but said access to basic pensions for the poor was far from everyday reality.

Welcomed by Juncker, Gentiloni

At the EU level, the prospective deal was welcomed by European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker during a visit to Sofia, Bulgaria.

Watch video 00:25

German coalition talks - Juncker: 'I'm very satisfied'

"I'm very satisfied content-wise with what the CDU/CSU and SPD have reached in terms of joint policies for the future," Juncker said, referring to Merkel's Christian Democrats and allied Bavarian Christian Social Union and Schulz's Social Democrats.

Prime Minister Boyko Borissov of Bulgaria, which currently holds the bloc's rotating presidency, said the EU was waiting "impatiently" for Merkel to reemerge, heading a new coalition: "for the benefit of all."

Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni commented via Twitter that the agreement between Merkel and Schulz was "a good item of news for Europe."

French President Emmanuel Macron said he was "happy and satisfied" that a new Merkel-led coalition was in sight. The coalition blueprint document commits: "in close partnership with France," to "sustainably strengthen and reform the eurozone so that the euro can better withstand global crises." 

SPD's Martin Schulz in Rome with Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni (Getty Images/AFP/T. Fabi)

Gentiloni (R) with Schulz last July

Schulz awaiting party endorsement

For the deal, Schulz said Friday he had the unanimous endorsement of the SPD's negotiating team, but he still needed clearance from a party conference to be held in Bonn on January 21.

Already, the SPD's youth and left-wing factions have renewed calls — made just after the party's electoral drubbing on September 24 — that the SPD should not enter into another coalition with Merkel and instead reinvent itself in opposition.

SPD defectors remain

"The mood amongst the delegates is still very fragile," leftist SPD Bundestag parliamentarian Hilde Matheis told the Schwäbische Zeitung newspaper.

The SPD ran the risk of handing the opposition role in parliament to the new-entrant far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD), she said.

AfD deputies in Bundestag (picture-alliance/dpa/B. von Jutrczenka)

AfD lawmakers in parliament

Another skeptical SPD parliamentarian, Marco Bülow, warned the deal would not ameliorate "great inequality" in Germany but boost left and far-right sentiment while further eroding decades of support for the SPD and Merkel's conservatives.

The SPD party base had to be mobilized, Bülow said, to "stop this grand coalition from within Social Democrats."

Should Schulz clinch party approval in Bonn, formal coalition negotiations could begin on January 22, resulting potentially in a new government formed by March.

ipj/tj (dpa, Reuters, KNA, AFP)

Watch video 13:57

CDU, CSU and SPD strike deal for coalition talks

DW recommends

Audios and videos on the topic

Albanian Shqip

Amharic አማርኛ

Arabic العربية

Bengali বাংলা

Bosnian B/H/S

Bulgarian Български

Chinese (Simplified) 简

Chinese (Traditional) 繁

Croatian Hrvatski

Dari دری

English English

French Français

German Deutsch

Greek Ελληνικά

Hausa Hausa

Hindi हिन्दी

Indonesian Bahasa Indonesia

Kiswahili Kiswahili

Macedonian Македонски

Pashto پښتو

Persian فارسی

Polish Polski

Portuguese Português para África

Portuguese Português do Brasil

Romanian Română

Russian Русский

Serbian Српски/Srpski

Spanish Español

Turkish Türkçe

Ukrainian Українська

Urdu اردو