Ece Temelkuran: My own great expectation for the German election

The German language enjoys an enviable richness and depth, writes Ece Temelkuran. The Turkish author hopes it will not succumb to primeval political discourse during the election.

It is not easy to fall in love with the sound of German language. For foreigners it is not the most welcoming language with its myriad of "artikels" [noun markers - Ed] creating a seemingly impenetrable fortress.

However, when you contemplate just how many legendary political and literary personalities have emerged from the German-language sphere to shape the modern world, you are inclined to deduce that there must be a particular aspect of this language that enables the intellect to mold the human condition.

It is as if the building block-like mathematics of the language creates an infinite scope for semantics and with it, an endless space in the human brain. This may explain why, contrary to recent elections in the West and in Turkey, words and ideas still matter in German elections – a sweet and distant memory which we in Turkey long for.

A few weeks ago when the Social Democrat (SPD) challenger Martin Schulz and Christian Democrat (CDU) Chancellor Angela Merkel held their TV election debate, educated Turks took to Twitter – sadly the only political and social Agora in the Turkish language – to reminisce the good old days of Turkish politics when such debates were a staple on TV channels, the fair fight of words and clash of political perspectives.

Watch video 01:47
Now live
01:47 mins.
Web-videos | 03.09.2017

Highlights from Merkel/Schulz TV debate

Since we are living in a world where the strongest nation is run by a man whose vocabulary is limited to 70 something words, I guess Turkey is not the only country that looks up to Germany and the manner in which German elections are conducted.

Global politics today is contaminated by a schizophrenic political discourse of which Turkey has a decade's worth of experience. Political language is degraded to the vocabulary of organized and mobilized masses, which leaves less and less space for basic rationale.

More importantly the intellectuals of the world, thanks to the social media and the Zeitgeist, are gradually finding themselves as gladiators in the same arena with the wordless crowd.

Ece Temelkuran

Ece Temelkuran

They are not "cool” thinkers and speakers of our world any more, but fighters who are equated with less educated individuals and therefore obliged to answer the wrong questions coming from masses. 140 characters are their arrows and their ideas and facts are desperately trying to attract attention in a social sphere where everybody is looking at themselves through their selfies.

In a world where even the intellectuals are degrading themselves to a semantic street fight, the masses are subjected to a certain type of political thinking I see no harm labeling infantile. This seems fair when millions voted to make "America great again" and "Britain great again" and leaders can mesmerize the masses simply with the word great.

German politics in particularly finds itself under such infantilizing pressure thanks to Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and his relentless attempts to influence the elections. He called on his supporters not to vote for "enemies of Turkey." This is a blatant call to support the AD-D, the party of Turks supporting Erdogan.

Related Subjects

Leaving aside the barefaced-cheek of a president daring to become a political actor in another country's elections, this attempt infuses a certain kind of mental status in German politics.


Between art and documentation

The range of themes covered in the exhibition is huge: refugees, the war in Syria, police violence in the Kurdish areas of Turkey, the construction boom and gender issues. Kürşad Bayhan's photos of bottles that have been decorated by Kurdish women symbolize the war-like conditions in southeastern Turkey.


The Human Chain of Suruç

Magnum photographer Emin Özmen focuses on the conditions in the Kurdish regions of Turkey. "Turkey's Hidden Wars" is the title of his black-and-white series. His works show water cannons and tear gas being used by the police and he captures curfew hours. His photo from January 2015 (above) shows Kurds forming a human chain in Suruç to support Kurdish fighters battling the "Islamic State" (IS).


Celebration despite war

Thousands of people came to the Newroz new year's festival in Suruç in March 2015, which took place despite the war. Above, men take a break during their journey. Suruç became a symbol of resistance to the IS. Emin Özmen considers his work to be like a documentary: "In order to find solutions to the massive problems in our region, we need to have a detailed picture of what is happening."


Refugees from Kobane

In his series "Moving Portraits," Barbaros Kayan focuses on the fears of refugees from Kobane who were being housed in camps in Turkey. He wanted to find out what happens when these people return to their home countries. Kayan traveled to Syria and documented the destruction and devastation there.


New conceptual imagery

Barbaros Kayan also photographed Syrians living in the Turkish refugee camps as part of the series. He placed their silhouettes on photos of their hometowns, creating compositions that confront the viewer with new visual themes.


Gentrification in Istanbul

Göksu Baysal mainly focuses on the construction boom and gentrification, especially in Istanbul, in his series "Istanbul Reloaded." The pictures depict violence against nature and highlight the rising demand for energy caused by the aggressive building boom.


Monotonous gray

Under the pretext of making the city safer against earthquakes, a program called "urban renewal" is replacing historic neighborhoods with gray landscapes built of concrete. The local population is often too poor to afford these new apartments and as a result is usually driven out of these areas.


Gezi - from protest to civil movement

What started as a protest against the building boom in Istanbul turned into the Gezi Park demonstrations of summer 2013. In his picture series called "Gezi," Kemal Aslan addresses the resistance of the population against the arbitrariness of the political system. For several weeks, thousands of people in Istanbul demonstrated for freedom and against oppression by institutions.


Women between autonomy and oppression

Since the Gezi protests, the role of civil society has become more prominent, and in particular the role of women. At the same time, however, violence against and murders of women continue to increase steadily. Emine Akbaba's series "Precious Blossom" focuses on women who are unable to free themselves from oppression.


Women as victims of violence

In international comparison, violence against women is extremely high in Turkey. Every other woman reports that she has been harassed on at least one occasion. Between 2010 and 2016, more than 1,600 women were murdered in the country. Emine Akbaba, winner of several photography awards, tries to raise awareness through her work about women's rights, gender equality, and freedom of expression.


'Isn't it love?'

Turkey's LGBT movement has also gained more attention since the start of the Gezi protests. "Isn't it love?" is the title of the series that Ceren Saner produced, which highlights images taken at queer parties. In this photo compilation, Saner questions the nature of love - not sexuality. In Turkey, the series is only shown during the Pride Week or at private events.

Germany more than any country knows best from history how such dichotomies as "the enemy" and "the loyal" damage the basic human rationale and how such primitive thinking shrinks the political sphere.

As we witnessed during French and Dutch elections, engaging Erdogan in a fight in their domestic political context won points for Western leaders. Emmanuel Macron and Mark Rutte prevailed in their elections partly because they made Erdogan one of the leading topics in their election periods. However, these victories came at a price.

Unfortunately once such primitive political discourse is welcomed, it is not easy to exclude its further inclusion in the political debate and it is almost impossible to quarantine it in social life. This is why the most important and difficult job for whomever wins the election, be it Merkel or Schulz, will be to protect the German language and politics from this infantile trend.

And this job will take more than pretending not to be afraid of Putin's dog or making a bewildered face in Erdogan's lavish palace as Merkel did.

More importantly, knowing that German language gave birth to some giants of human thinking, I have the right to assume that the leader of the German people can do better than making arms deals with Turkey while criticizing human rights violations in the country.

I am always amazed during the many readings of my novels how the German audience keeps still and listens carefully for 30 long minutes. Among all the countries in which my books are published, Germany is where I deeply feel that my each and every word is listened to and heard.

I never presumed that it was my amazing talent that created the beautiful silence, but rather the unique ability of German readers to appreciate the words.

While the world and its politics are becoming more and more "wordless" and when the global political noise is withering with fewer and fewer ideas, Germany is one of the last fortresses where one can depend on words and thus the human capacity to think.

I therefore expect German political leaders to become Ralphs of our global island of "Lord of Flies" to beat the Jacks of our times. 

Ece Temelkuran is an award-winning Turkish journalist and author. She was fired from her job as a TV presenter in 2011 for criticizing the Turkish government over the Uludere massacre. She has published 12 books, which have been translated into a range of languages.