German municipal association advises towns to sell data

Towns and cities in Germany should be willing to earn money selling data, a municipal umbrella organization says. The recommendation comes amid a debate fueled by the Facebook scandal.

German towns should sell data they have collected on topics such as noise pollution and traffic density to boost their revenues, according to an umbrella association representing their interests.

"Towns and municipalities have to become more aware that data is the oil of the 21st century and can be used to gain significant income," Gerd Landsberg, the managing director of the German Association of Towns and Municipalities (DStGB), told the daily Rheinische Post on Monday.

He said town councils possessed "valuable records" that they should not just make available free of charge, as has previously been the case, but instead use them for the benefit of their residents. He proposed a "franchise model" in which private companies could operate using the data that they paid for.

Watch video 01:59
Now live
01:59 mins.
Business | 28.12.2017

Security experts: businesses need to do more to protect cu...

Read more: Surveillance and human rights in the digital age 

Widespread opposition

Landsberg's proposal met with considerable criticism from several quarters.

Andrea Vosshoff, who heads Germany's top data protection authority, warned that viewing personal data solely in a financial sense "reduces people to products."

She pointed out that the public was very aware of the problems associated with the trade in data.

"Even if using anonymous data is not problematic from the point of view of data protection, I warn against branding all such measures as harmless," she said. "In today's era of digitization and big data, there are ways of connecting up supposedly anonymous and thus harmless data in such a way that it becomes possible all of a sudden to make inferences about individual people after all."

Read more: Big science: is Big Data really the price we 'have to pay' for advanced research?

Ongoing debate

The Left Party's parliamentary spokeswoman for internet policy, Anke Domscheidt-Berg, said that if such data were sold, big companies would be the ones to benefit rather than the general public.

Related Subjects

Watch video 04:10
Now live
04:10 mins.
Made in Germany | 07.03.2018

Viviane Reding on data privacy

"Ultimately, it means that mostly profit-making applications would be developed and little or nothing for the public good," she said.

The topic of data protection has been brought to the front of public debate in Germany as elsewhere by the scandal surrounding revelations of misuse of personal data from Facebook for political purposes .

German postal service Deutsche Post recently also faced allegations that it sold customer data to clients including political parties for use in election campaigns.

The company has rejected the claims made against its subsidiary Deutsche Post Direkt, saying it adhered completely to Germany's strict data protection laws.

Read more: Facebook scandal: Data scraping knows no borders

tj/se (AFP, dpa)

Each evening at 1830 UTC, DW's editors send out a selection of the day's hard news and quality feature journalism. You can sign up to receive it directly here.