1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

UN slams France anti-terror bill

Nicole Goebel
September 27, 2017

UN human rights experts have warned France that the planned legislation could have "grave consequences" for civil liberties. They fear a permanent state of emergency.

https://p.dw.com/p/2kpfZ
Soldiers patrolling in Nice
Image: Reuters/E. Gaillard

The UN's Human Rights Office has expressed concern about a French draft law that translates as a "bill to strengthen internal security and the fight against terrorism."

It could affect people's "right to liberty and security, the right to access to court, freedom of movement, freedom of peaceful assembly and association, freedom of expression and freedom of religion or belief," according to a statement by two UN human rights rapporteurs, Fionnuala Ni Aolain and Michel Frost.

Read more: Macron:Fighting Islamist terror France's top priority

The draft law, which was passed by the senate and is now being debated in the National Assembly, would incorporate temporary measures granted to authorities in a state of emergency into ordinary law.

'Vague wording'

In the statement, the two UN experts criticize the "vague wording" of the bill, which they say does not define terrorism nor the threats to national security sufficiently well. Ni Aolain and Frost are also worried that Muslims may face "discriminatory repercussions."

They argue that a government's options for cracking down on terrorism are "limited by its compliance with international human rights standards."

That means that a state of emergency must be proportionate and have a time limit, according to the statement.

French President Emmanuel Macron argues that the law is necessary to combat terrorism and foil further plots once a state of emergency imposed in 2015 expires.

France marks one year since Nice terror attack